Part 5: North Richmond man
on July 6, 2011
Most of North Richmond is unincorporated. That means the residents here don’t can’t vote in city elections, and can’t lobby the City Council for grievances.
For more than a decade, one man has been the de facto elected representative of the nearly 3,000 residents of unincorporated North Richmond. He is a trim, unfailingly polite man who recoils at formality (“Call me John,” he insists), who has an office in El Cerrito and serves within a legislative body that meets in Martinez. His sprawling west Contra Costa County district includes East Richmond Heights, El Sobrante, Kensington, and Montalvin.
While not universally supported by local leaders, particularly those who see the county government as a hindrance rather than a supporter of progress, John Gioia has amassed numerous achievements in representing a community that amounts to a politically insignificant share of his overall constituency. He is a political powerhouse whose reign atop District 1 looks impervious to challenge.
“Politically, Gioia is awfully strong,” said Vernon Whitmore, publisher of the Richmond Globe, one of the Richmond area’s two black-owned newspapers. “He’s seen as a guy who can get things done, get resources to Contra Costa County.”
Gioia, 53, grew up in West Contra Costa County, and has a broad coalition of support and deep roots in the area. His father, E. John Gioia, was a longtime civics teacher at Richmond’s Kennedy High School and a highly-respected Richmond resident. Gioia credits his dad, who died in 1987, with instilling in him the importance of public service.
Gioia graduated from El Cerrito High School before attending U.C. Berkeley, where he earned a BA in 1979 and a law degree in 1982. A photo of the father and son near Zellerbach Hall on graduation day sits on a shelf in Gioia’s office.
The younger Gioia started a local legal practice, and was elected in 1988 as a Director of the East Bay Municipal Utility District, where he served for 10 years before his election to the County Board of Supervisors in 1998.
Politically, he is seen as a solid liberal. In the late 1970s, Gioia was a founding member of the Contra Costa County’s Young Democrats Club. But he is not as far to the left as the new generation of progressive Richmond city council leaders, led by Green Party Mayor Gayle McLaughlin. Gioia consistently receives the endorsement of the Contra Costa County chapter of the Black American Political Action Committee, an organization studded with longtime Richmond political leaders that has opposed McLaughlin and other farther-left candidates like Councilwoman Jovanka Beckles. Gioia was a supporter of former Mayor Irma Anderson, whom McLaughlin narrowly defeated in 2006.
“Gioia has the support of the old guard in Richmond,” Whitmore said.
Gioia says he has a particular fondness for North Richmond. It’s where he met his wife, who came to North Richmond in 1999 as a member of a U.S. Department of Education task force to work on a federally-backed project aimed at improving the community.
“It’s a community in which there was there is a history of a lot of really open and committed community leaders,” Gioia said, mentioning revered names like Fred Jackson, Willie Spears and Lee Jones. “I have really developed an attachment to these great people.”
Gioia said he has always been driven by a desire to do what he can to infuse development into North Richmond. “For a long time, many people thought that all the vacant land in North Richmond was poised for a future of being developed into an industrial area with a lot of jobs for local residents,” Gioia said. “And back in the early 1990s the county zoned huge swaths of vacant land for industrial use. But now, the future I see for North Richmond is housing and mixed use commercial, and I am optimistic.”
Among his accomplishments in the late 1990s, Gioia made headlines by criticizing Chevron Corp. into developing a preparedness plan—which it previously didn’t have—in case of a disaster, the fallout of which would no doubt acutely impact North Richmond residents.
In 2003, Gioia teamed with State Sen. Loni Hancock and then Richmond Mayor Anderson in an unsuccessful opposition to a new Wal-Mart store at Hilltop Mall. Gioia, who has gained a reputation for being solidly pro-development, clashed with Wal-Mart over the corporation’s aggressive local lobbying efforts and concerns that a super-store would impact traffic and surrounding businesses.
Around that time, Gioia also co-authored, along with former supervisor and now State Senator Mark DeSaulnier, a county ordinance, which did pass, to give the county greater control over whether to approve large Wal-Mart Supercenter-style stores. This drew national attention, and Gioia appeared on Bill Moyers’ Frontline on PBS and on Bill O’Reilly’s The Factor on Fox News.
In one of his most heralded accomplishments, Gioia took a lead role in 2006 in providing Doctors Hospital in San Pablo with a $10 million loan when the facility was facing closure. To date, the county has loaned the hospital $20 million to keep it open, Gioia said, and he also chairs the hospital’s governing board in an effort to guide it onto firmer financial footing.
“It’s more than the loan, its the actual work of getting more state funding, as well as funding from other area hospitals,” Gioia said.
He’s also credited with establishing a mitigation fund, paid for by the nearby landfill and transfer station – which sit in both city and county territory and emit airborne and other pollutants into North Richmond – which is marked for investments in the neighborhood. The fund collects revenues through a fee on all trash brought into the waste transfer station, and has brought millions into North Richmond since 2006.
In 2007, he earned resounding support from the North Richmond community, and from some of the leaders who now oppose him, for his lead role in forcing the closure of Golden 7, a liquor store in the 500 block of Market Street that had become a magnet for drug sales, loitering and violent exchanges.
But Gioia acknowledges that inducing more business development in North Richmond has its challenges. Like many residents and historians, Gioia makes special note of how “vibrant” and “lively” North Richmond was during the immediate postwar years and the 1950s. Sitting in his El Cerrito office one day in late 2010, he breezily flipped through stacks of books on Richmond that he stocked on the shelves of his office, pointing out sections that refer specifically to North Richmond.
But the reality is that the heyday is long gone. The community has been in a long slide, aided by unfortunate geography, history and political configuration. “Certainly, being near a landfill, near a sewer treatment plant, near Chevron, near General Chemical, surrounded by railroad tracks, these things have all contributed to North Richmond being perceived as a less than desirable place for investment,” Gioia said. “And this is an area that would flood periodically even after World War II.”
Gioia has been in office since 1998, and the last 13 years have been a mostly grim time in North Richmond’s history. During this period, crime has spiked at times to Third World rates, money for public housing projects has dried up and the nationwide housing collapse decimated the already fragile community.
Violent crime is down in the last two years, but the homicide rate remains much higher per capita than in the city of Richmond. Gioia said that increasing sheriff’s deputy patrols in North Richmond probably played a role in reducing overall crime. The beefed up patrols were paid for by a combination of mitigation funds, redevelopment funds and money from the Housing Authority and County Health Department that had been used to provide security at the North Richmond Center for Health.
In the early 2000s, as the ill-fated housing boom was just taking off, North Richmond seemed poised to prosper, Gioia said. Nowhere had cheaper land in the Bay Area, and values were on the ascent, attracting eager buyers who were more likely to look in places they otherwise would not consider in search of affordability.
KB Homes, the national housing developer, built a major development of single family homes in the in the early 2000s, hoping to capitalize on the upswing in housing demand and prices. Prices for homes in North Richmond were scaling unprecedented heights, moving well over $500,000 for a basic 3-bedroom home. But in the ensuing years, as the economy slowed and the housing market went bust, Gioia says sales were sluggish and prices fell drastically. Houses remained empty. Developers did not meet projections. Buyers saw their investments in North Richmond crater.
Residents and buyers also quickly began having misgivings about the tract’s neighbor — the Las Deltas Housing projects — and demanded that walls and fences be built to provide a clear dividing line.
Today, even with some of the cheapest land prices in the Bay Area, interest is tepid. “People were looking at moving in or investing in property for a time, but that has changed,” Gioia said. According to the county Assessor’s Office, modest, older homes are scattered all over North Richmond are valued at less than $100,000.
Today, any development, county-supported or otherwise, is exceedingly difficult to get off the ground. With virtually no retail businesses in the neighborhood, the perception of pollution, spotty public transit and a persistent crime problem, kickstarting investment in the area is difficult.
As one example, Gioia said there is a building in the 1500 block of Third Street, next to the Sheriff’s substation, that is particularly bothersome. “We’ve been trying to get a market into that building for a long time,” he said, pointing to the approximate spot on a map of North Richmond that hangs on his conference room wall. “It has been really hard to get someone in there.”
Why the trouble? “No one wants to move in there without an alcohol permit, and we don’t want to give them one,” Gioia said.
Gioia said that the county has also had to close businesses in recent years due to illegal activities and non-compliance with basic regulations. “One store went from a family-owned and operated to ownership by unscrupulous owners,” Gioia said. “It had numerous code violations.”
The neighborhood, which was solidly African American for decades after World War II, is now changing demographically, which is most evident on the Richmond city side, where streets bordering the southern railroad tracks are dotted with homes that fly the flag of Mexico.
“The neighborhood is nearly half Latino now,” Gioia said, adding that the continued infusion of new, working families must be part of the neighborhood’s growth in the future.
Gioia firmly believes that North Richmond will have a future of growth, particularly in housing and retail and commercial investment. He said that the he’ll push for a vote this year to rezone the largely vacant, formerly industrial lands to the north of current housing stocks, an action which would allow for developers to build homes and retail centers in the area.
The spot could become a magnet for new homeowners and young professionals looking for affordable housing in the Bay Area, Gioia believes. The location’s proximity to Bay Area job centers and the nearby San Rafeal Bridge could be a strong incentive. Regional transportation infrastructure, like BART and Amtrack lines, have been developed nearby in recent years. Specific plans developed by the county lay out an enticing vision of North Richmond as the Bay Area’s next hot spot for affordable housing and new homebuyers and working families.
At the same time, Gioia said he has strong interest in developing Urban Agriculture in North Richmond in a way that preserves and honors the a North Richmond history of family farms and greenhouses. “We want to be ready for when the market turns around.” Gioia said, “because the area is well-positioned.”
Gioia is not alone in thinking that North Richmond is brimming with potential. Richmond City Councilman Jim Rogers, in a guest column that appeared in the Alameda Times Star on March 13, 2010, argued that North Richmond’s shoreline is a misused jewel. Rogers noted that much of the city’s — and North Richmond’s — extensive shoreline was long ago claimed by industrial interests in a hasty land grab that did not take into account the public good.
But Gioia has his critics, who accuse him of neglecting North Richmond and making poor choices in terms of resource allocation.
Mister Phillips, 32, a local attorney, is one of Gioia’s most vociferous critics; he challenged Gioia for his supervisor seat in 2010.
While Gioia trounced Philips at the ballot box, his unsuccessful campaign did highlight the plight of North Richmond. During his failed bid, Phillips railed against what he called “horrible” conditions and inadequate public safety, problems he laid firmly on Gioia’s doorstep.
“Those of us who have spent significant time in North Richmond know the county has failed to provide North Richmond basic public services like street lights, which has contributed to crime in the area,” Phillips said during an interview in May.
Phillips’ campaign against Gioia was unsuccessful in part, some observers believe, because he spent too much time focusing on the plight of North Richmond. A community so poor and so small doesn’t pay much in terms of ballot box dividends.
Phillips said he has no regrets. “The county has under-served North Richmond, because North Richmond’s county supervisors have allowed the county to under-serve North Richmond,” Phillips said in May. “When a county supervisor tells the people there is little to nothing he can do about poor service by county departments, he is not being honest.”
Another detractor who has raised his profile in recent months is Rev. Kenneth Davis, a North Richmond community leader who has organized protests at Gioia’s El Cerrito offices and has let fly with whithering criticisms. Davis’ ire was prompted in part by Gioia’s role in allocating money from the mitigation fund.
Although Gioia is just one vote on a seven-member committee, Davis has charged that the supervisor’s influence is a major factor in allocating hundreds of thousands of dollars of mitigation funds annually to the county Sheriff’s Department in the form of salaries for additonal deputies in North Richmond.
Davis also says that Gioia has done nothing to prevent the community’s mitigation funds from being used to subsidize a sheriff’s force that patrols the wealthier suburbs of Contra Costa County. “What type of leadership would cut job training to subsidize law enforcement?” Davis said. “Exactly the kind of leadership that continues to destroy North Richmond.”
Davis led a protest at Gioia’s offices in April.
Gioia dismissed the protests as not representative of the community’s concerns and instead a play by Davis and his ally, former urban farming supervisor Saleem Bey, to secure public dollars for an “Eco-Academy” youth training program, which would be run by Bey. Becnel gave back $175,000 that had been marked for the academy – to be run by Bey – because of run-ins that she said she had with Bey. That money will be reallocated to another program by the committee, which includes Mayor Gayle McLaughlin, Councilman Nat Bates and North Richmond environmental activist Henry Clark.
Gioia said that he and the committee have unanimously voted on how to spend the mitigation funds and have provided ample resources to youth programs and gardening initiatives, but that increasing deputy patrols is crucial to keeping the community safe. The criticism he received, Gioia said in April, “is about Saleem Bey intimidating the city and the county to give him money without a proposal showing proper accountability for the dollars, period.”
Nevertheless, Davis has called Gioia a “slave master,” and “poverty pimp,” alleging that the supervisor is a leader of a county system that looks to enrich agencies, especially the sheriff’s department, rather than solve the community’s problems of poverty, pollution and violence. The slurs strike a deep chord with the normally sunny Gioia, whom contemporaries describe as a man who cares deeply about maintaining support among his African American constituency. Gioia has maintained good working relationships for years with neighborhood civil rights icons like Fred Jackson and Barbara Becnel, who runs the North Richmond Neighborhood house.
“Nothing is ever surprising to me,” Gioia said of Davis’ charges. “People who know me and my work with the African American and Latino communities know that I don’t need to respond to that.”
Gioia has his staunch supporters, too. Joe Wallace, a longtime resident and member of several neighborhood associations, said Gioia’s reign has been comparatively good for North Richmond.
“Under John’s leadership North Richmond has come up,” Wallace said. “I don’t think most of his critics were in North Richmond in the 1960s, and 1970s and 1980s when every time you turned the corner people were getting killed and the sheriff’s and police were running rampant out here.”
“John has been a great supervisor for North Richmond mostly because he has worked with and encouraged the formation of community boards and organizations that get residents involved and provide accountability,” Wallace continued. “If you are creating community organizations and the supervisor is not in your corner, your hands are tied.”
Although Gioia is a long-serving politician deeply ensconced in his seat, he insists that his eye is on North Richmond’s future. “We must have that plan in place so that when the real estate market does turn around, we are prepared,” Gioia said. “But in the meantime, we have to make the community safe for the residents today, not just tomorrow.”
Richmond Confidential welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Richmond Confidential assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.
Richmond Confidential is an online news service produced by the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism for, and about, the people of Richmond, California. Our goal is to produce professional and engaging journalism that is useful for the citizens of the city.
Please send news tips to firstname.lastname@example.org.