Skip to content

Efforts to save Iron Triangle church end in arrests

on March 18, 2011

Pastor Sydney Keys received an eviction notice for Bible Way Apostolic Church last week, and mobilized the church community to keep the building continuously occupied starting Wednesday, when the property was to be vacated. He was arrested Thursday.

Two days of civil disobedience to save the Bible Way Apostolic Church from foreclosure ended yesterday when Contra Costa sheriff’s deputies arrested Pastor Sydney Keys, his wife, mother and two other activists.  Members of the congregation took turns keeping the building continuously occupied since they received an eviction notice on March 9 telling them they had to leave the building by this Wednesday.

The church has been embroiled in a dispute with its mortgage holder, Torrey Pines Bank, and has fallen behind on its $6,800 monthly payments.

Gracie Ivy, who has been a part of the congregation for nearly six years, was in the church cooking a meal for Mary Keys, the pastor’s mother, and waiting for the pastor and his wife to return from San Francisco when the sheriff’s deputies arrived.

“He told me, kept telling me you gotta turn the food off, you gotta leave, you’re being evicted,” Ivy said.  She said she was tricked into leaving the building and was not allowed back in.  She said felt terrible for leaving the pastor’s mother alone in the church.

Ethan Larudee joins the crowd's chant of "Save our church!" while blocking the sheriff's car containing Pastor Keys and his wife from leaving the church.

Shortly after Ivy left the church, the pastor and his wife arrived.  They were arrested along with Mary Keys.

Dozens watched from outside the locked gate shouting “Let them go!” and “Save our church!” as Dr. Keys and his 80-year old mother were led in handcuffs from the church and put into a police car.  Patrice Keys, the pastor’s wife, was led out shortly afterward, as protesters, including Mayor McLaughlin’s aide Marilyn Langlois, pleaded with the deputies and argued that the arrest was unjust.

“What good will it do to arrest her?” Langlois asked the deputy.

Four protesters sat down in front of the gate to block the cruiser containing Dr. Keys and his mother from leaving.  They were forced out of the way by deputies, and two were handcuffed and arrested.  One of them, Paul Larudee, stayed limp and three officers dragged him screaming across the street amid a crowd of protesters, eventually wrangling him into a patrol car.

Shamika Newman, a member of the congregation, watched the arrests with angry tears.  “They put an 80-year-old woman of God in handcuffs,” she said.  “This is not right.  They help people, they deserve to be rewarded.   This is the devil’s work.”

Ethan Larudee, son of Paul Larudee (pictured), said that police used excessive force in detaining his father, who he said was peacably resisting.

The five were taken into custody for resisting arrest, according to sheriff’s office spokesman Jimmy Lee. They were taken to the county jail in Martinez.

“It’s an unfortunate situation and we don’t ever want things to get to that point,” he said. “There was a notice of eviction and it was served to the church on march ninth so Wednesday they should have left and they stayed another day.”

In a letter supporting the church, Richmond Mayor Gayle McLaughline called Bible Way a “treasured resource” in the Iron Triangle community. Since its founding nine years ago, the church has built out its social programs. The church was recently licensed to open a childcare program so that teen mothers could go to school or work.  Church members also serve meals, organize youth activities, and offer official and unofficial support groups in the community.

Gracie Ivy said that beyond the formal services the church offers, Dr. Keys and his wife are both vital members of the neighborhood.  “Pastor Keys is like a father to so many teenage boys who are outta control,” she said.  “And his wife is like a mother to the community. She got her degree in childcare so she could open up the nursery and preschool and give single moms a place for their kids to be safe when they go to work.”

Patrice Keys was taken into custody as the crowd pleaded with the deputies to let her go.

Torrey Pines Bank, which took over the church’s mortgage after absorbing original lender Alta Alliance Bank, foreclosed on Bible Way after the church fell behind on its $6,800 monthly payments.  Pastor Keys has called the loan “predatory,” and said that his and his wife’s signatures were forged on income statements, resulting in a monthly payment too high for the church to afford. A lawyer representing the church has petitioned to halt the eviction until an investigation can be made into the pastor’s allegations.

In a press release, Torrey Pines Bank said their staff worked with Pastor Keys for over a year, extending their collections protocol to find a solution and allow the Keys to “substantiate their claims in appropriate legal proceedings over the past many months.”  The statement said the bank “understands and regrets the disappointment of those who have been affected by this situation However, any suggestion that the Bank acted improperly or illegally in any way is simply untrue.”  It also said the bank is not aware of any investigations into the issue.

“This church needs to be here and needs to keep ministering in this area,” said Claire Haas, a community organizer with the Home Defenders League, a division of the Alliance for Californians’ Empowerment, which was founded last year to advocate on behalf of homeowners facing foreclosures.  The non-profit helped to organize the sit-in at the church and coached members of the congregation on civil disobedience.

Gracie Ivy was cooking dinner for Mary Keys inside the church when the sheriffs deputies arrived to serve an eviction notice. Here, she looks through the cruiser window at Patrice Keys.

Tanya Dennis, who was also arrested for blocking the gate, is an activist with the Home Defenders League and recently faced foreclosure on her own home in Oakland, but she was able to get the order rescinded with the help of similar actions from the organization, said Claire Haas.  “She saw the same thing happening, and now it’s her turn to help others,” Haas said.

Claire Haas said the five people who were arrested were released at 1:30 Friday morning from the county jail in Martinez.  She says she does not know what charges have been brought against them.  The pastor could not be reached for comment.


  1. SYLVIA HERNANDEZ on March 18, 2011 at 3:42 pm

    It is a sad Day when a church is attacked like that…so i am guessing that it is better to take down a church and teach our childern nothing is to be respected…better for you to run the streets of Richmond then to be in church and hear the words of our lord….

  2. tsuggs on March 18, 2011 at 4:01 pm

    If this was the result of a “predatory loan” why did not the church leadership question it sooner?

    Too many people entered into mortgages that they could not afford. Is it really the banks fault or just people biting off more than they can chew?

    If a church is to be respected, then should not we also teach our children that the law, civil contracts and our word, needs to be respected also?

    We need to stop blaming others for our own mistakes.

  3. Juan Reardon on March 19, 2011 at 11:55 am

    I admire Richmond activist Paul Larudee who had the courage to stand against this abuse of the Rev Keys, his fanmily and the Bible Way Apostolic Church. Paul Larudee was also part of the 2010 GAZA Liberation flotilla in solidarity with the blockaded Gaza people in Palestine. He was rough-up by Israeli soldiers then as he was abused by Sheriff deputies today. Thank you Paul! Viva Richmond! Viva Gaza!

  4. Naomi Williams, Community Activist on March 20, 2011 at 11:48 am

    I am really concerned, if all the bank wanted to do was to evict the persons from the property, they did that. Was it neccessary to take them to Martinez from Richmond?, When they could have removed them from the property, which they did, and let the Pastor and his family go. I asked that question to one of the deputies sheriffs, he said that was a good question, but he was not incharge. I tried to get the deputy sheriff that was incharge attention, but could not. I know there is the “Letter of the Law”, but there is also the “Spirit of the Law” that I believe could have been used in this case. I know the sheriff was doing their job but Each case is difference.
    Were they booked or were they just released in Martinez?

Richmond Confidential welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Richmond Confidential assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Card image cap
Richmond Confidential

Richmond Confidential is an online news service produced by the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism for, and about, the people of Richmond, California. Our goal is to produce professional and engaging journalism that is useful for the citizens of the city.

Please send news tips to

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top