Skip to content

The American Dream?

on October 5, 2010

Francisco has dreams. They are good dreams, but not legal ones. The 24-year-old from Zelaya, Mexico, arrived under the undocumented coattails of his parents when he was just five years old. Today, after the failure of legislation called the “Dream Act,” Francisco’s hopes of becoming a schoolteacher must be put on political hold.

Introduced in 2001 by Sen. Orin Hatch, of Utah, The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act, commonly referred to as the DREAM Act, would allow children of undocumented immigrants the chance to gain citizenship by graduating college or by serving two years in the military.

The bill’s logic is simple. Children of undocumented immigrants do not have a say as to where they live, but they can still plan and invest in their future by becoming productive members of America’s society. Opponents, however, feel illegal immigrants are “illegal” and taxpayer money should not be focused on those who are not citizens.

Francisco has been in the United Sates all but five years of his life. "I always wanted to go back to Mexico for nostalgia, but I just can't — I can't visit my home back over there," said Francisco.

The immigration act piggybacked on a larger defense bill that included the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy regarding gays serving in the military. Needing 60 votes to pass, the motion fell short by four votes: 56 to 43.

“If the DREAM Act came true it would be a huge opportunity to me,” said Francisco. “I’d be on my way to being a schoolteacher. It would definitely be a dream come true to me.”

Francisco spotlights his frustration with a joke.

“What is the difference between race and being a magician?” Francisco asked. “They both create illusions,” he said with a smile.

Francisco has lived in Richmond since he was five, attending local schools and graduating from Richmond High. At school, he says, students know who is a legal resident and who is not. Those with documentation get help and guidance. Those without often lose hope.

“I had a friend, Jose, that always wanted to join the military,” said Francisco. “Then one day in the 12th grade he just dropped out of school. He was like, ‘Why am I going? I can’t even get a job here.’ He just bailed out totally.”

Francisco says being an undocumented immigrant is no walk in the park. Applying for insurance or obtaining a driver’s license is impossible. Not to mention the mental hurdle of hearing media outlets define them as criminals.

“Illegal immigrants aren’t the ones bringing drugs into this country — we just want work and a better life,” said Francisco. “Another thing I see is the misconception that most illegal immigrants get welfare — the thing is we can’t even get it.”

Many immigrants attend church. "We just want work and a better life," said Francisco.

But beyond the political, cultural and language barriers, there is something else: a nine-number code that everyone needs to make a living — a Social Security Number.

In order to work most undocumented immigrants obtain false Social Security Numbers. This is what Francisco did.

“You go over to the Mission and just by walking around and dressing and looking like you’re an immigrant they’ll pull you off the street and ask if you want a Social Security Number,” said Francisco. “It’s an underground operation.”

But there are risks. When Francisco applied for financial aid while as a student at a local college, officials then discovered that not only was his Social Security Number false, it also contained a felony charge.

“Can you imagine what would happen to me for things I didn’t even commit,” said Francisco. “My mistake was using a fake number.”

Unable to afford tuition because the college could not offer financial aid without a proper Social Security Number, Francisco was forced to drop out of college.

And so the game of cat and mouse begins.

Francisco believes big business has something to do with the difficult passage of the DREAM Act. As for the failing legislation, Francisco is resigned to his lack of power in American society.

“Illegal immigrants are scapegoats in this country,” said Francisco. “But in reality big businesses like their cheap labor.”

Francisco hopes immigration reform happens in his lifetime, but is well aware that it’s pretty far away right now.

“It’s always good to keep hopes — we can only do what we can do,” said Francisco.

In the meantime, Francisco will keep working and contributing to his community as a volunteer where he works with local kids. Even if he never becomes a citizen he wants to give back.

“What I would really love though, is if I could be someone that kids can go back and say, ‘Oh he was working like that and he didn’t have the papers that I don’t have — at least he did something.’ I hope they can look back one day and say ‘I remember that guy!’”


  1. mark wassberg on October 5, 2010 at 10:30 am

    You illegal latinos have no right being in the U.S. you sneek across the U.S. border and are MS13, drug dealers but it dosen’t matter you have no right being in the U.S. You come into the U.S. illegally and clam that you are a U.S. citizen breaking all U.S. laws, you are criminals and that is U.S law

    • Anthony Walker on October 5, 2010 at 2:02 pm

      hehe, that’s all you took away from that story?
      This is about CHILDREN who have no say in the actions of their parents. They have grown up in our system, our way of life, our customs and traditions. To say they have no rights is absurd. If you wish to vilify their parents for whatever perceived slight to you and yours, feel free. But don’t take it out on children who are just trying to make the best of a shitty situation.

      • mark wassberg on October 7, 2010 at 9:02 am

        Children or no children and new born, if you are in the U.S. illegally they need to be arrested and deported back to Mexico. that is the LAW stupid.Load all of they up in box cars and ship them back to Mexico, end of story!

        • Josh Williams on October 8, 2010 at 9:26 am

          We love that our site is increasingly becoming a platform for Richmond residents to voice their opinions, to us, civic leaders and to one another.

          The goal of our story comments is to elevate discussion on our site. We encourage debate and critical analysis of the issues we cover. But in order to maintain meaningful debate, we require that commenters follow a few simple rules, all of which are articulated above the comment form on all stories. Our main request is that participants in our discussions remain civil and refrain from personal attacks and name calling. Please help us maintain a space that encourages real debate.

Richmond Confidential welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Richmond Confidential assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Card image cap
Richmond Confidential

Richmond Confidential is an online news service produced by the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism for, and about, the people of Richmond, California. Our goal is to produce professional and engaging journalism that is useful for the citizens of the city.

Please send news tips to

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top