Skip to content

Tempers flare on council as pair of flotilla survivors return home

on June 15, 2010

There are now two weeks and thousands of miles separating Kathy Sheetz from the melee that she found herself involved in on May 31, when the Israeli navy raided a humanitarian flotilla of boats trying to deliver aid to Gaza, capturing Sheetz and 677 other activists and killing nine people. But it isn’t totally behind her yet.

“When I got back to the United States, I realized that everything had been confiscated from me on the boat,” Sheetz, 63, said. “I found out that my credit card had been stolen there [and since used]. So in a way, I felt like it wasn’t over. … That violation and that idea of having no security. …  There’s something about that that made me bring it home with me.”

Sheetz was one of two Richmond residents present at the Richmond City Council meeting Tuesday who were taken prisoner by Israeli forces two weeks ago when the Freedom Flotilla, which was carrying aid supplies to Gaza, was stopped in international waters. Paul Larudee, the other Richmond resident aboard the ships, also returned home this week. The two were on hand at Tuesday’s meeting to hear the council discuss the adoption of a resolution condemning the Israeli raid, but following a tense and vociforous standoff on the council, the issue was referred to the city’s Human Rights Commission instead.

Allen King, a Richmond business owner, holds up an image of the Israeli flag during Tuesday's council meeting in response to several pro-Palestinian members of the crowd. Photo by Ian A. Stewart.

The tabled resolution, which would have supported a U.N. condemnation of Israel’s actions taken during the flotilla raid, quickly turned into a suprisingly divisive issue for the council. Several members of a packed crowd at Tuesday’s meeting held up pieces of paper displaying the Palestinian flag and cheered as Mayor Gayle McLaughlin, who heads the Human Rights Commission, said, “This is so clearly a human rights issue with so much pain. I know the Human Rights Commission will do it justice.”

Two councilmembers, Maria Viramontes and Nat Bates, each questioned why the mayor would introduce such a resolution, arguing that the city council had no business weighing in on international politics.

“This is something we have no control over,” Bates said. “Israel and Palestine don’t give a damn what Richmond thinks.”

His statement was met with a mixture of cheers and boos from the crowd. Once the issue was tabled, the crowd thinned out considerably.

The flotilla, organized by a Cyprus-based group called the Free Gaza Movement, was to deliver food, medical supplies and construction supplies to Gaza City, where the group says that 1.5 million people live in virtual isolation and are denied basic supplies by the Israeli government. The flotilla was stopped before it reached Gaza and boarded by armed Israeli forces, who killed nine of the activists. The incident has drawn international outrage and led to terse relations between the U.S. and Israel, a longtime ally.

Israel and Egypt have blocked maritime access to the Gaza strip since 2007, when the militant Islamist group Hamas took control of Palestine.

After the raid, Sheetz was taken to an Israeli prison, and eventually transported by Turkish officials to Istanbul, and then to New York. She returned to the Bay Area late Saturday night before arriving at Tuesday’s council meeting.

Sheetz, a retired nurse and mother of three grown children, moved to Richmond about a year ago from Marin with her partner, Steve Greaves, a preschool teacher. Greaves expressed frustration with not only the Israeli response to the flotilla, but with the lack of response from the U.S. government.

“My own government did not rescue my wife — it was up to the Turks to rescue her,” Greaves said. “They gave her a hotel room and a plane ticket to come back to the United States. My government completely failed it its duties to protect my wife. It’s shameful.”

Sheetz, who has taken part in two other similar humanitarian trips to Gaza — one successful and one that was stopped by Israeli forces — said that despite the violence this trip, the awareness it raised made the ordeal at least partly a success.

Betty Larudee holds a photograph of herself with husband Paul Larudee earlier this month. Paul Larudee was one of two Richmond residents aboard the beseiged Gaza flotilla. Photo by Ian A. Stewart.

“It’s always dangerous to do this,” she said of trying to break the blockade. “But if that keeps us from doing it — and I think our government is too weak to do it — then this [oppression] will just go on forever. This was an awful tragedy, but we’re going to go back. This has just increased the amount of people interested in participating in this non-violent effort to end the blockade.”

Larudee, the other Richmond resident aboard the flotilla, had been taken to Greece after the stand-off, where he recuperated from injuries he suffered during the raid, before flying home. Larudee says he was beaten and tased by Israeli forces while in prison. An Israeli ambassador in San Francisco has since confirmed that Larudee required medical care, but did not say how he suffered the injuries.

An Associated Press photograph of Larudee arriving in Greece showed severe bruising on his arms.

Lindsey Baggette, a family friend who has been living with the Larudees in their home in the Richmond hills, said in an email that he is still recovering.  “You can still see a lot of his bruises, but he’s healing OK,” she wrote. “I guess he still has joint pain, but hopefully that will go away soon.”

McLaughlin, who has already personally condemned the Israeli attacks, and Vice Mayor Jeff Ritterman sponsored the proposed council resolution. McLaughlin said during the council dust-up Tuesday that the Human Rights Commission would report back to the council to discuss the resolution, although she said it may be several months before that happens.


  1. Dave on June 17, 2010 at 7:43 am

    Several months to have this reported by to the council ? Clearly this isn’t about human rights but campaigning for mayor. I’m worried about job my local charity the boys and girls club. What does this have to do with. Richmond . Bring back our jobs and businesses “

  2. Hannah King on June 17, 2010 at 1:50 pm

    Hello Ian. I think that the article “Tempers flare on council as pair of flotilla survivors return home” is one-sided and seeks to agitate, instead of report. The agitation begins with the title—I would not call the people who returned home “survivors,” but “activists.” Next, the Israeli navy did not “raid a humanitarian flotilla of boats.” Instead, they boarded the ships, which is legal under international law when a country is at war, and Israel is at war with Hamas, an international terrorist organization that has vowed to kill every Jew. The article continues, “The flotilla was stopped before it reached Gaza and boarded by armed Israeli forces, who killed nine of the activists.” It is terrible that 9 people were killed; any loss of life is tragic. However, 5 of the 6 ships were boarded peacefully and without incident. It was only on one ship where the Israelis were attacked that they defended themselves and sadly people were killed in the skirmish. I think it is important to note that the Israelis were attacked and defended themselves; they didn’t just step on board and kill 9 people.

    The activist groups supporting the flotilla say that 1.5 million people are denied basic supplies by the Israeli government, but in fact, the Israeli government supplies between 100 and 120 trucks daily filled with food, medical supplies and humanitarian goods. I think that this could have been included in the article to make it less one-sided. Israel is seeking to keep supplies that can be used for weapons out of Gaza so that it can stop the rockets that are fired into Israeli cities (and these rockets have killed innocent civilians going about their daily lives).

    The situation between Israel and Gaza is complex and many people (and countries) are trying to find a peaceful solution. In Richmond, and other cities, let’s work for peace in our own communities and set an example for the rest of the world.

  3. luis mora on June 22, 2010 at 3:10 pm

    This is the USA. When is this country going to wake up and stop the consistent $10B a year in direct aid to Israel. If you love Israel go and live there but do not continuously pull the US in to this mess. We should not be a default for this Jewish state.

Richmond Confidential welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Richmond Confidential assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Card image cap
Richmond Confidential

Richmond Confidential is an online news service produced by the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism for, and about, the people of Richmond, California. Our goal is to produce professional and engaging journalism that is useful for the citizens of the city.

Please send news tips to

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top